How markets work
Can Retail Traders Beat Institutions?
By Alex J. Wang, Market Research, SEPT Investing · Published · Last updated
Short answer: Yes, it's possible, and small traders have real advantages that big funds don't. A retail trader has no benchmark to beat, no clients pulling money out, and can get in and out without moving the price. Being small isn't what makes most retail traders lose. Three things do: a lack of knowledge, a lack of tools and data, and a lack of discipline. That means chasing highs, buying dips with no signal, holding losers and hoping, and mixing trading styles. The best-known study, covering every trade in Taiwan's market, traced virtually all individual losses to individuals' own aggressive orders. A trader with a plan, the right data and strict exits can use the flexibility funds don't have. Win rate alone hides the problem: when SEPT tested 71,922 breakout trades, 64.4% won, but the average loser was almost twice the average winner. That doesn't mean never losing: in a broad selloff like this week's, almost nobody, retail or institution, gets through without losing money. The difference is keeping losses small and planned. 中文版
Education, not financial advice.
"Retail is just exit liquidity." Not quite.
You'll often hear that small traders are only there so big funds have someone to sell to. It happens, mostly in hyped tiny stocks and "group chat" picks, where early buyers dump on late ones. But it isn't a law of the market. It's what happens to traders without a plan.
The research points the same way. Barber, Lee, Liu and Odean studied every trade on the Taiwan Stock Exchange from 1995 to 1999. Individuals lost about 3.8 percentage points a year as a group, while institutions gained about 1.5. But the authors traced virtually all individual losses to aggressive orders: buying and selling right now, at whatever price, and trading far too often. The losses came from how people traded, not from the fact that they were small.
And being big doesn't guarantee winning: in 2025, 79% of actively managed US large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500 (S&P Dow Jones Indices).
The edges a small trader has that funds don't
- No benchmark. A fund manager can be fired for trailing the index for a year. You can sit in cash until a setup you trust appears.
- No forced selling. Funds must sell when clients pull money, often near the lows. You don't, unless you use borrowed money.
- Small size. You can enter and exit in seconds without moving the price. A big fund can take days to build or leave a position, and it pushes the price against itself while doing it.
- You can wait for them. Big buying and selling leaves footprints in price and volume. A small trader can wait for those footprints, then follow: buy after big buyers have shown up, and sell before they leave.
- You choose your games. You don't have to trade every day, every stock or every market.
What actually holds most retail traders back
1. Knowledge. Most people start trading without knowing how price moves around key levels, what volume is saying, or how to read a company's results. They trade on tips, headlines and feelings.
2. Tools and data. Institutions have research teams, real-time data on who's buying and selling, and software to test ideas on years of history. Most retail traders have a basic chart and a news feed.
3. Discipline. This is the biggest one:
- Never enough. A trade is up, the target is hit, but they hold for more, and watch it come back.
- Chasing highs. Buying after a stock has already run, because it's moving and everyone's talking about it.
- Buying dips without a signal. "It's cheap now" is a feeling, not a reason.
- Holding losers and hoping. The stop is hit, but they don't sell. The loss grows.
- Mixing time frames. A short-term trade goes red, and suddenly it's a "long-term investment." A long-term holding goes green, and they sell it like a quick trade. They end up running losers like investments and winners like trades: the exact opposite of what works.
What disciplined traders do differently
- Keep long-term and short-term separate. Long-term holdings are owned for years and aren't traded on daily moves. Short-term trades have their own rules and are never allowed to turn into "investments."
- Every short-term trade has a stop and a target before entry, and both are followed strictly.
- Take the money you can see. Sell at the target without regret, even if the stock keeps going. There will be another trade.
- Trade only what you understand: the price action, the levels, and the company's basic story.
- Wait for confirmation. Let price show that real buyers have stepped in before buying, instead of guessing the bottom.
None of this makes a trader immune. In a market like this week's, disciplined traders lose money too, just like the big funds. The difference is that their losses are small and planned, so they still have money and confidence to trade when the market turns back.
Closing the knowledge and tools gap
This gap is why SEPT exists. It gives individual traders the kind of data and tools that used to belong to professionals (how SEPT works):
- key levels computed from every trade, with what price did there before;
- real buying vs. selling from every trade;
- a screener you write in plain English;
- backtesting to test a rule on past data before risking money;
- paper trading to prove it in real time.
The discipline part is still up to you, but it's much easier to follow a plan you've tested.
That's the idea behind SEPT: simple, emotionless price-action trading. Make the plan first, then let price decide.
Related
- Where Does the Money Go When the Stock Market Drops?
- Do Institutions Make Money When the Market Falls?
- What Do Institutions Do When the Market Is Falling?
- Is This a Market Crash or Just a Correction?
- Should I Sell Everything When the Market Drops?
- What Really Moves a Stock's Price?
- Why Do I Keep Losing Money Trading?
FAQ
Are retail traders just exit liquidity for institutions?
Mostly not. It happens in hyped small stocks and pump-and-dumps, but research shows most retail losses come from their own trading habits: chasing, overtrading and paying up to trade immediately.
What advantages do retail traders have over institutions?
No benchmark to beat, no forced selling when clients withdraw money, the ability to get in and out without moving the price, and the freedom to wait for the right setup.
Why do most retail traders lose money?
Mostly a lack of knowledge, tools and discipline: chasing highs, buying dips without a signal, holding losers, and mixing short-term and long-term thinking.
Do institutions always beat the market?
No. In 2025, 79% of active US large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500.
We email a confirm link first. Unsubscribe any time. Tools and data, not investment advice.
Want to check your own trades instead of guessing? Start free with SEPT → Beta Pioneer is $29.99/month, open to join until Jan 2, 2027; the price holds while you stay subscribed.
Education, not financial advice. Trading involves risk, including loss of money.