SEPT research
Can Breakout Trading Make Money? We Tested 71,922 Breakouts on 10 Years of Data
By Alex J. Wang, Market Research, SEPT Investing · Published · Last updated
Short answer: not the way most people trade them. SEPT research tested breakouts at the most-watched price levels on 10 years of 1-minute data. They won 64.4% of the time — and still lost money, because the losing trades were almost twice as big as the winners. Simple opening-range breaks did no better than a coin flip on direction.
Hypothetical results on past data, 2017–2026. Real fills were not measured. Past results do not promise future results.
Want more odds data like this? SEPT research has measured 10 years of 1-minute data across millions of trades and stock-days, and new studies are published as they pass validation. Sign up free with SEPT → to follow the research and test your own ideas on SEPT's data.
Why we tested it
"Buy the breakout" is one of the first strategies new traders learn: price pushes through yesterday's high or the morning range, you get in, and the move carries you. It's simple, it's everywhere, and it feels right when it works. We wanted to know what it actually does over thousands of trades.
How we tested it
- Data: 1-minute bars for US stocks, January 2017 to November 2026, 4:00 AM–8:00 PM ET.
- Which stocks: only liquid names — a normal daily range of at least $1 and at least $40 million traded per day, re-checked every day.
- The levels: yesterday's close, high and low; yesterday's after-hours high and low; the full 24-hour high and low; today's premarket high and low.
- The rule: three 5-minute candles close past the level in the first hour, with price clearly past it (at least about a fifth of a normal day's range). Enter at the close of the third candle. Long trades only when the daily trend was up.
- Stop: the nearest level just behind, plus a small buffer. Target: half the position at a measured target, the rest at the same target or the 3:55 PM close.
- Costs: 1 cent per share in and out.
- Check: the data was split into 2017–2021 and 2022–2026. A result only counts when both halves agree. A trade that matched several levels at once was counted once.
Results are shown in "R", the amount risked on one trade. +1R means you made what you risked; −1R means you lost it.
The result: a 64% win rate that loses money
| Trades | Win rate | Average winner | Average loser | Per trade | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All breakouts | 71,922 | 64.4% | +0.58 R | −1.08 R | −0.012 R |
| 2017–2021 | 28,799 | −0.016 R | |||
| 2022–2026 | 43,123 | −0.010 R |
⚠ A 64% win rate here still loses money. Winners averaged +0.58R; losers averaged −1.08R. You win about two trades out of three — and the third one takes it all back and more.
- By level: we split it 18 ways (each level, long and short). 16 of the 18 lost money. The two near flat — premarket-low breakouts — didn't hold up in both halves.
- Filters didn't save it: 168 filter combinations looked profitable on 2017–2021. On 2022–2026, only 32% stayed profitable, and the "best" picks lost money there. Finding a filter that worked in the past is easy; finding one that keeps working is not.
- Costs make it worse: it already loses at 1 cent per share. Every extra cent of slippage adds to the loss.
Opening-range breaks: mostly false starts
The opening range is the high and low of the first 5, 15 or 30 minutes. We counted every break of it — over 900,000 to 1.1 million of each kind — and asked a simple question: how far does price get before it closes back inside the range?
| Opening range | Breaks | Went 0.10 ADR before coming back | 0.25 ADR | 0.50 ADR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5-min, up | 1,137,467 | 37.4% | 20.3% | 10.8% |
| 5-min, down | 1,131,080 | 38.1% | 20.8% | 11.0% |
| 15-min, up | 1,004,742 | 33.7% | 17.6% | 8.9% |
| 30-min, up | 901,103 | 31.1% | 15.9% | 7.6% |
ADR = the stock's average daily range. The 0.25 ADR numbers match in both halves (e.g. 5-min up: 20.6% / 20.1%).
In plain words: about 4 in 5 opening-range breaks come back inside before moving even a quarter of a normal day's range. And the direction after a 5-minute range break was a coin flip: price moved a quarter of a day's range with the break 46% of the time and against it 47% of the time.
It wasn't just breakouts
We ran the same kind of test on 19 popular intraday events — high-of-day and low-of-day breaks, gap fills, red-to-green and green-to-red days, VWAP reclaims and rejections, round-number reactions, premarket high/low breaks, opening-range breaks and failed breaks — each with hundreds of thousands to over a million cases.
Every one landed within about ±0.01R per trade before fees. Fees wipe that out. Across 1,276 extra filter combinations, none passed our bar (a profit factor of 1.2 or more, holding in both halves).
We even coded one of our own trader's hand-written rules for trading key levels — 18 rules in all. Over one year on 360 stocks it took 51,223 trades and lost 0.05R per trade. ⚠ Written-down rules fired far more often than the trader actually trades — and that gap between "the rule" and "the judgment" is part of the finding.
So can breakout trading make money?
The simple version, on its own, didn't in our data. That doesn't mean no one makes money trading breakouts — it means a breakout alone is not an edge. What's missing is usually the part that's hard to write down: which breakouts to skip, how to size, and where the stop really belongs.
What the data does point to:
- Win rate means nothing without loss size. Always ask for both.
- Test on two separate periods. A rule that only works on the years you built it on is a story, not an edge.
- Count your costs. Many small edges are smaller than a few cents per share.
- Some things did hold up. Our separate study of reversals at key levels (the opposite idea: price touches a level and turns) passed both halves — with a small edge of a few cents per share that slippage of about 2 cents per share removes. Small, real and fragile is what an honest edge often looks like.
How SEPT tests ideas
Every SEPT study uses the same method: 10 years of 1-minute data, liquid stocks only, split-half checks, overlapping trades counted once, costs included, and every result labeled — validated, tested-not-profitable, withdrawn. We keep failures on record and we've published our own corrections, like an after-hours "63% win" that was really 41% once we fixed how it was measured.
SEPT Investing is a trading strategy automation platform. Describe your strategy in plain words; GOAX, SEPT's AI assistant, helps turn it into an exact rule; then scan, alert, backtest and paper trade it on SEPT's own data, built from every trade — before any real money is at risk. SEPT's odds tables, like the numbers on this page, are in research now and not a live feature yet.
For more data on trading odds, sign up with SEPT → — Free tier available. Beta Pioneer: $29.99/month, available until Jan 2, 2027.
Related: Big Day Yesterday? What Usually Happens the Next Day · The Best Way to Use AI in Trading
Cite this research
SEPT Investing Research, "Can Breakout Trading Make Money? We Tested 71,922 Breakouts on 10 Years of Data," November 2026, https://septinvesting.com/learn/can-breakout-trading-make-money. Data: US stocks, 1-minute bars, 2017–2026, split-half validated, 1¢/share costs.
FAQ
Does breakout trading work?
In SEPT research, a standard breakout rule at key levels won 64.4% of 71,922 trades but lost 0.012R per trade on average, because losers (−1.08R) were nearly twice the size of winners (+0.58R). 16 of 18 level-and-side versions lost money.
Why can a high win rate still lose money?
Because the size of wins and losses matters as much as how often you win. Winning 64% of the time at +0.58R while losing 36% at −1.08R adds up to a small loss per trade.
Do opening-range breakouts work?
About 4 in 5 opening-range breaks came back inside the range before moving a quarter of a normal day's range, and direction after the break was close to 50/50 (2017–2026, over 1 million breaks per range type).
Can filters fix a losing breakout strategy?
Not in our test. 168 filter combinations were profitable on 2017–2021, but only 32% stayed profitable on 2022–2026, and the top picks lost money there.
What is "R" in trading?
R is the amount you risk on one trade, from entry to stop. Results in R let you compare trades of different sizes: +2R means you made twice what you risked.
How does SEPT test trading strategies?
10 years of 1-minute data on liquid US stocks, results split into 2017–2021 and 2022–2026 and only trusted when both agree, overlapping trades counted once, 1¢ per share costs included, and every study labeled — including the ones that failed.
Not financial advice. Hypothetical results on past data (2017–2026). Real fills (slippage) were not measured; results include 1¢ per share each way only. Past results do not promise future results. Trading involves risk, including loss of money.