How markets work
Do Institutions Make Money When the Market Falls?
By Alex J. Wang, Market Research, SEPT Investing · Published · Last updated
Short answer: Most don't. The bulk of institutional money (pension funds, mutual funds, insurers and many hedge funds) holds large long-term stock positions, so when the market falls they're losing money on paper too. What they do differently is use knowledge and tools to lose less: hedging with options and futures, trimming risk, and collecting option premium while they wait. "Institutions" also covers very different players. In 2022, when the S&P 500 fell about 19%, the average hedge fund lost about 4%. Funds that bet long and short on stocks lost about 10%. Macro funds, which trade rates, currencies and commodities, gained about 14%, and the largest hedge funds as a group ended slightly positive. Ordinary stock mutual funds mostly fell with the market, because their job is to stay invested. Market makers earn the bid-ask spread, so they depend more on how much trading happens than on whether prices go up or down.
Education, not financial advice.
"The big players must be cashing in while I lose"
It's a common belief: when the market drops, institutions short it and get rich off everyone else. The real picture is messier, and more reassuring. Most big money loses in a falling market too. A smaller group is set up to profit, and even that group doesn't win every time.
Look at a real bear market: 2022
2022 was one of the worst years for stocks and bonds in decades. Here's how different institutions did, according to Hedge Fund Research data:
| Who | 2022 result |
|---|---|
| S&P 500 | about −19% |
| Average hedge fund (HFRI Fund Weighted Composite) | about −4% |
| Equity hedge funds (long/short stocks) | about −10% |
| Macro hedge funds (rates, currencies, commodities) | about +14% |
| Largest hedge funds (HFRI Asset Weighted Composite) | about +1% |
A few of the biggest multi-strategy funds posted large gains that year, but they were the exception, not the average.
Why most institutions lose when the market falls (and try to lose less)
- Most big money is long-only. Pension funds, mutual funds and index funds are built to own stocks. When stocks fall, they fall. Their goal is to beat their benchmark or match it, not to make money every year.
- They can't just leave. A fund can't sell everything and sit in cash; that's not what its clients pay for. Some must even sell when clients pull money out, often near the lows.
- Size is a problem. Getting out of a huge position takes days and pushes the price down on the way.
- So they protect instead of exit. They buy puts or sell index futures as insurance, trim some shares, and sell options against what they hold to earn premium. One common move: sell part of a position and, at the same time, sell puts below the price. If the stock keeps falling and the put is exercised, they buy those shares back cheaper. If it doesn't, they keep the premium. See What do institutions do when the market is falling? for the numbers.
Who can profit, and how
- Macro and trend funds trade futures on rates, currencies, commodities and stock indexes, so they can profit when trends are strong in either direction. 2022 was a good year for them.
- Short sellers and long/short funds can gain on the stocks they bet against, but their long positions usually lose at the same time.
- Option sellers and volatility traders can earn more when fear is high and option prices rise, but can lose heavily in a sudden crash.
- Market makers earn the spread on every trade. Busy, volatile days often mean more trading, though very fast markets also carry risk for them.
What this means for you
- "The institutions" aren't one team. They often take opposite sides of the same trades.
- Falling markets are hard for nearly everyone. If you lost money in a drop, you were in large company, including many professionals.
- Their real edge is knowledge and tools, not magic. They know their worst case before it happens, and they hedge for it. That's the part a small trader can copy.
- What the winners share is preparation. The funds that made money in 2022 had positions and hedges set up before the drop. They didn't react in a panic after it. You can copy the preparation, if not the strategy: plan your exit and size before you're in the trade.
That's the idea behind SEPT: simple, emotionless price-action trading. Make the plan first, then let price decide.
Related
- What Do Institutions Do When the Market Is Falling?
- Can Retail Traders Beat Institutions?
- Where Does the Money Go When the Stock Market Drops?
- Is This a Market Crash or Just a Correction?
- Should I Sell Everything When the Market Drops?
- What Really Moves a Stock's Price?
- Why Do I Keep Losing Money Trading?
FAQ
Do hedge funds make money in a bear market?
Some do. In 2022, the average hedge fund lost about 4% while the S&P 500 fell about 19%. Macro funds gained about 14%, and equity long/short funds lost about 10%.
Do mutual funds lose money when the market falls?
Most stock mutual funds do, because they're built to stay invested in stocks. Their goal is usually to match or beat a benchmark, not to avoid every loss.
How do market makers make money?
They buy at the bid and sell at the ask, earning the small difference on huge numbers of trades, while hedging to limit how much they lose when prices move.
Should I short the market like the big funds?
Shorting has risks that owning stock doesn't, including losses with no fixed limit if the price rises. Most funds that profit in drops use hedges, strict sizing and many years of experience.
We email a confirm link first. Unsubscribe any time. Tools and data, not investment advice.
Want to check your own trades instead of guessing? Start free with SEPT → Beta Pioneer is $29.99/month, open to join until Jan 2, 2027; the price holds while you stay subscribed.
Education, not financial advice. Trading involves risk, including loss of money.